Illinois Court Upholds Parental Notification Law
Friday, July 17th, 2009After more than a decade of legal battles, a federal appeals court in Illinois has ruled to uphold a previously unenforced state parental notification law. Effective August 4th, young women under 18 will be required to notify a parent or guardian 48 hours before getting an abortion.
While the law does not require that teens receive consent from a parent, even notification can create unnecessary and dangerous barriers to accessing reproductive health services for young women. Parental notification laws assume that teens can safely involve their family in the decision to terminate a pregnancy—which is sadly not always the case. Also, most teens already involve their parents in their decision to terminate a pregnancy. For the small minority who do not involve parents in this decision, it is usually for good reason, like in cases of abuse or incest. And, like other abortion restrictions—such as mandatory counseling and waiting periods—parental notification restrictions tend to result in more second-trimester abortions.
Soo Ji Min, Executive Director of the Illinois Caucus for Adolescent Health, a grantee of the National Institute’s Urban Initiative, issued a strong statement condemning the ruling:
The American Medical Associate reports that some young women will go to extreme and unhealthy lengths to keep pregnancies secret, including running away, obtaining illegal abortions, or self-inducing abortions. Over half of young women who do not involve a parent in their decision to seek an abortion cite fear of abuse or eviction. Requiring parental notification or consent can expose young women to these risks.
Parental notification laws like this one are just another restriction designed to prevent women from accessing their legal right to an abortion—and end up doing more harm than good.
By Maya Dusenbery